Scholarly Journal v. Magazine Articles:
How can you tell the difference?

Some things to look for:

 
Magazine Articles
Scholarly Journal Articles
Audience
  • Written for the general public.
  • Written for scholars in the field.
Authors
  • Journalists and writers.
  • Not necessarily experts in the field.
  • Often credentials are not provided.
  • Experts in the field.
  • Credentials normally provided.
Editors
  • Evaluated by staff editors, not experts in the field.
  • Reviewed by a group of experts in the field before being published. (Peer reviewed, refereed, or juried.)
Writing Style &
Format
  • Non-technical language, easy to read.
  • Usually include glossy color photos and illustrations.
  • Advertisements are usually present.
  • References or bibliography not usually included.
  • Scholarly language and specialized terminology of the field.
  • Can include charts and graphs related to the text, but don't normally include glossy color photos.
  • If advertisements are present, they are for other scholarly materials such as books and journals.
  • References and bibliography are always included.

If you still aren't sure:

Check Ulrich's Periodicals Directory (available at the reference desk).

Or, ask a reference librarian for help!

 

2/03 MDH